02

Blog

Hit and Run Driver Leaves License Plate Behind, Pays In the End

Here’s a tip for any would-be hit and run drivers out there:  Make sure you do not leave your vehicle’s license plate at the scene before you flee.  We will find you.

That’s what happened after a husband and wife struck a Chicago bicyclist at the intersection of North Franklin Street and West Hubbard Street.  Recently, we made them pay, resolving the case for more than eleven times the amount of our client’s medical bills.  It is very unusual for an Illinois personal injury case to settle for an amount so much in excess of a victim’s medical bills.

The incident took place on the afternoon of May 7, 2012.   Our client, a 23 year old man, was riding his bike south on Franklin.  When he reached the intersection of Franklin and Hubbard he stopped at a stop sign before beginning to turn left to proceed east on Hubbard.  The couple was north on Franklin in a 2011 BMW 535Xi.  The wife was driving, her husband seated next to her in the vehicle.  Initially, she stopped at the intersection.  But, as the cyclist passed in front of her, in the midst of his turn, she accelerated striking the right side of his bike with the front of the car.  The cyclist’s face collided hard with the pavement cracking two of his front teeth.  The driver stopped for a moment.  She saw that the young man was bleeding from his mouth.  He spit out pieces of his broken teeth onto the sidewalk.  The front passenger side window was down and, shouting over her husband, she said that the crash was not her fault then sped away.  The couple shared no information about who they were.

As the cyclist stood there shocked and bloodied a man who witnessed the collision from an “El” train pulling into the nearby Merchandise Mart station approached.  He said that he saw what happened and shared his contact information.  As the two of them stood there they saw something unexpected laying in the street,  the front license plate from the vehicle.  The cyclist figured that it had lodged between his chain ring and bike’s frame and pulled free.  When he brought the license plate number to us it was easily to get title information on the vehicle and to track down the owner.  The plate itself was turned over to the Chicago Police Department.  Strangely, and disappointingly, it turned out that the driver was a former United States ambassador to a European nation.  Her husband is the founder of a very well known Chicago real estate company.  Apparently, breeding and basic human decency do not necessarily go hand in hand.

Once we contacted the couple we hoped that they would do the right thing.  Our client needed extensive dental work and was compiling medical and dental bills he could not afford to pay.  He did not have health insurance.  Better angels failed to appear, however.  The couple and their insurer refused a very reasonable settlement proposal.  We filed a lawsuit alleging both negligence and willful and wanton misconduct.  The case remained in litigation for years.  I took the depositions of the driver and her husband.  Neither were repentant in the slightest.  During the husband’s deposition, with a look of annoyance, asked if I was nearly done.  He had “important” business to attend to.  He remained under examination until I felt quite sure that he had provided me with all of the information I required.

The possibility of punitive damages was very real.  Different from compensatory damages, punitive damages are meant to punish a wrongdoer rather than to compensate an injury victim for medical bills, lost wages and pain and suffering.  Punitive damages are only in play where it can be proven that a defendant was not merely negligent but either acted with malicious intent or with a reckless disregard for the safety of another person.  There is case law in Illinois that allows a jury to consider punitive damages where there was flight from the scene of a crash.  We felt that we had at least enough evidence to put the issue to a jury.  The defendants faced the very real possibility that a jury would be outraged by their conduct and could penalize them substantially.  Insurance does not and cannot pay an award of punitive damages.  We felt that the possibility of punitive damage made the defendants and their insurance company willing to bargain and reach a settlement.

Comments

Bike Law Kickr Review
Feb 20, 2017

A 500-mile initial review of the Wahoo Kickr Indoor trainer, why we purchased it and who we think it is for.

Read More
Hazards of Biking with a GoPro or Garmin
Feb 15, 2017

Did you know that there are reasons for riding with and without cameras strapped to your handlebars and embedded within your tail lights?

Read More
Cycling Law Enforcement Training in Georgia
Feb 10, 2017

CBS Atlanta News This past November, Fulton County elected a new sheriff. (Yes, there’s literally a New Sheriff in Town.) During the run-up to the election, one of the candidates posted a tasteless video of John Wayne shooting guns and seemingly taking out cyclists. This created a huge backlash. One of the candidates for Sheriff, […]

Read More
2017 Moving People Forward Conference
Feb 08, 2017

This past Monday I attended the Moving People Forward conference in downtown Denver. The conference was hosted by Bicycle Colorado in lieu of their annual Colorado Bike Summit which has been moved to later in the year. Leaving the conference I had mixed emotions from my attendance. As I boarded the commuter rail back to my […]

Read More
Olga Cook Ghost Bike
Feb 02, 2017

The New Jersey man charged with felony manslaughter for striking and killing cyclist Olga Cook in the bike lane on the West Side Highway has agreed to plead guilty to all charges.

Read More
Bike Law - 2017 Fat Bike Nationals
Feb 01, 2017

A recap of the 2017 Fat Bike Nationals held in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Words from Bryan Waldman, and photo credit goes to Bike Law cyclocross racer, Wade Burch.

Read More
Cyclist Stop Sign
Jan 30, 2017

Bike Law fully supports the Colorado Safety Stop Law, Senate Bill 93, that was introduced by Senator Andy Kerr to rethink the, “Operation Of Bicycles Approaching Intersections”.

Read More
Bike Law USA Cycling Team
Jan 26, 2017

As a step toward increasing the safety of cycling and advocating for the rights of cyclists, we are pleased to announce a partnership between the Bike Law Network of Independent Bicycle Attorneys and USA Cycling.

Read More
Bike Law Michigan Mechanic Award
Jan 17, 2017

Bicycle mechanics are referred to as the unsung heroes of the peloton. They are also the unsung, and often unrecognized, heroes for local bike shops and most cyclists. Show some love for your mechanic by nominating him/her to be considered for the Bike Law Michigan Mechanic of the Year Award. 1 winner will receive a […]

Read More
Bike Law Manifesto 02
Jan 16, 2017

Our second principle is a gentle reminder of why we always turn to the bike.
“Nothing else allows us the independence, pleasure, and power to move so far, so fast, with so little effort.”

Read More
Michigan Needs Better Cycling Laws
Jan 13, 2017

After two years of a dramatic increase of bicyclists killed by car crashes in Michigan, there is a clear connection between these deaths and the lack of laws to protect cyclists.

Read More
DC Motor Vehicle Collision Recovery Act
Jan 12, 2017

In 2016, the Washington Area Bicyclist Association (WABA) was a standout group in their unrelenting advocacy work to push forward the Motor Vehicle Collision Recovery Act protecting all vulnerable road users.

Read More
Load More