Call

Blog

Law
02

Blog

NY Civil Judge Takes Driver’s License (after police wrongly found deceased cyclist at fault)

Distracted, Speeding, and you kill a cyclist? Arrested? Ticketed? Nope.  Welcome to New York. Well, Dan Flanzig changed the ending to this story.

In the summer of 2014 Matthew Brenner was struck and killed by a motorist on Sands Street underneath the Manhattan Bridge in Brooklyn. From the moment of the crash there was more questions than answers. At the scene of the crash, the driver was not arrested or even issued a summons under NYC’s Right of Way Law. The NYPD seemed to perform the bare minimum of investigation which only helped to keep Matt’s family in the dark. 

It quickly became apparent that the details of Matt’s crash, as cited by the NYPD, didn’t make sense. Yes, he was riding against the flow of traffic. We also knew there was an available buffered bike lane in the area that Matt failed to use. But even if Matt made these mistakes, why that night did he have to die? Matt was a former bike messenger and an experienced rider. He knew how to handle himself in traffic.

Shortly after the crash, Matt’s mom Franci retained our office. We began our own investigation while the NYPD conducted theirs. We interviewed witnesses, took photos and retained a traffic expert to see if the road configuration and lack of signage in the area may have contributed to the crash.

Several months later we were granted access to the NYPD Collision Investigation Squads (C.I.S.) file relating to the crash. Within the file was a video taken from a NYPD security camera which depicted the event. The video showed what we expected. An unanticipated and sudden move by the driver of the car. While attempting this move, she struck and killed Matt.  Here is a still photo from the NYPD video cam:

Bike Crash Location in NY

Still from NYPD Video Camera of Crash Location

One would think that this manner of driving would be clear and convincing evidence for the NYPD that the driver held some culpability in causing the crash. But this was not the opinion of the NYPD. The matter still was not referred to the District Attorney’s office for criminal charges. The NYPD stood fast in their opinion that the fault of the crash rest solely with Matt. The driver’s insurance company aligned with the police and refused to settle the claim.   

We commenced a lawsuit against the driver. Several months later, she appeared for her deposition. At that time we discovered things that the NYPD failed to explore. She testified that on the night of the crash she was late to pick up her friend up at the airport. Being unfamiliar with the area, she was relying on google maps to get her to JFK. During the deposition, we spent a great deal of time discussing her route, road, and lane position immediately prior to the crash, an area the police totally failed to explore.  Being lost, we learned that she shifted suddenly from the middle lane of the roadway and onto the entrance ramp of the BQE as a result of being prompted by google. This required her to cross over two lanes of traffic to get to the entrance ramp where she ran head on into Matt. We further learned that right before she made this sudden lane change, she was tailgating the vehicle in front of her. Given the manner in which she was driving, she had no chance to see Matt and Matt to see her. In fact, the first time she saw Matt at all was after the impact. All of these factors were never addressed by the NYPD in coming to their conclusions.  

Here’s the daytime aerial photo of the scene:

daytime-arial

Daytime Arial Photo of Scene

Following the drivers deposition, her insurance company settled the case. Her testimony was too damming to survive a trial. However, our fight was still not over. We wanted her held accountable for Matt’s death. Matt’s mom and I had one more stop. A New York State, Department of Motor Vehicles, Fatality Hearing.

In New York State, any driver who is involved in a crash which results in a death is required to attend a statutory Fatality Hearing to determine whether they should be fined or driver privileges suspended.  These hearings are supposed to be mandatory. Matt’s mom and members of Family for Safe Streets, a New York City Advocacy group hounded the DMV until it a hearing was scheduled. The hearing, by statute is too held within 60-90 days of the crash. Matt’s was not scheduled for almost two years. Again, welcome to New York.

On a cold March day at a hearing office in lower Manhattan I appeared with matt’s mom Franci. A few members of Family for Safe Streets joined us as well.  Not surprising, the driver who was subpoenaed failed show. In lieu she submitted a self-serving affidavit prepared by her lawyers. The NYPD investigating officer also failed to show. Thanks again NYPD. It looked like it would be up to us to present the evidence to the Administrative Law Judge presiding over the hearing.

We provided the Judge with a copy of the crash video and the driver’s deposition. We argued that the evidence collected showed that the driver made a sudden lane change onto to the BQE ramp without signaling, that she was driving too fast under the circumstance, and crossed over the safety island in order to enter the BQE. We further argued that driver inattention and distraction by way of being lost and distracted by looking at google maps was the cause of the crash.  The Administrative Law Judge took it all in and was incredibly sympathetic to Franci. We left the hearing feeling like she heard us but we were unaware whether she would take any action against the driver given the Police findings. At best, we hope for a slight fine. 

Several weeks later we received the results of the hearing. For one of the first times in New York State, absent criminality, alcohol or drugs, the Judge REVOKED her driving privileges in the State of New York.  The Judge agreed with our presentation that driver, who was lost, distracted by the use of google maps, was traveling at an unsafe speed, did not signal her turn, and crossed over the solid white lines of the safety triangle contributed to the crash. 

The Judge went onto to hold “had the [driver] been traveling at a safe speed in the proper entrance ramp lane it is probable that the Decedent would have seen her and not cross the street. In addition, had she been in the proper lane and traveling at a safe speed it is probable that she would have seen the Decedent and been able to make attempts to avoid hitting him”.

The Judge further found the driver violated 4 sections of New York State Vehicle and Traffic law and for each of the violations, revoked the driver’s license and/or driving privileges in the State of New York.

While the NYPD, the District Attorney’s Office, and the Insurance Company all got it wrong, we were able to prove what we always knew, Matt was not the cause of his own death.

Nothing will ever heal the pain of a mother losing a child, but knowing that the driver has been held responsible and that Matt was not to blame, has provided some solace in this sad and tragic event.

Comments

Ann Groninger Jan 04, 2024

Many of our cycling clients find themselves having to interact with the criminal justice system. Typically, it’s because the driver who hits them (or their family member) is charged with a crime or traffic offense. Occasionally bicyclists themselves are charged with traffic offenses! Every state’s criminal laws are different, but there is a lot of […]

Read More
Bike Crash Road Defect Georgia
Peter Wilborn Jun 14, 2023

We recently shared the story of a trial victory from the State of Texas where a bicyclist was injured due to a defect in a road maintained by the Texas Department of Transportation. Texas Road Defect   We now can tell the story of another huge win in a road defect case, this time from […]

Read More
Road defect dangerous to cyclists
Charlie Thomas Mar 14, 2023

Recently, attorneys with the Bike Law network took a case to a trial against a titan of a defendant: the Texas Department of Transportation. TxDOT was represented by the Attorney General’s Office, one of Texas’ largest legal teams. We had a great client, but it was a tough case to prove. So tough, in fact, […]

Read More
bike path charlotte
Ann Groninger Jan 13, 2023

  2023 got off to a rough start for Charlotte, North Carolina, particularly in the context of road safety. Within about a week, we lost a young woman who was riding her bicycle, a pedestrian killed in the same area of town, and four people were killed in a car wreck on I-85 in the […]

Read More
North Carolina Bike Crash
Ann Groninger Dec 06, 2022

Unless you’re a very recent follower of ours, you’ve heard us talk before about “contributory negligence.” To recap: “pure contributory negligence” is the law in North Carolina and only 3 other states (Alabama, Virginia, Maryland). In pure contributory negligence states, if a person is injured by someone else’s fault and the injured person contributes even […]

Read More
Is It Illegal to Ride Your Bike on the Sidewalk bikelaw
Peter Wilborn Aug 01, 2022

The laws dictating whether you can ride your bike on the sidewalk differ depending where you live. Different states have different laws on this matter, and local ordinances also vary. Let’s take a look at the legal framework behind various state laws related to cycling on sidewalks. The laws of sidewalk-riding can be very complicated […]

Read More
Ebike crash
Bruce Hagen Apr 26, 2022

DRIVER ON METH KILLS 17 YEAR OLD BICYCLIST, BARROW COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY REFUSES TO CHARGE DRIVER WITH FELONY.   On August 23, 2020, at approximately 8:40pm, 17-year old Obianuju Osuegbu was on her way home from her summer job working at a grocery store. She had earned enough money that summer to buy herself a […]

Read More
Stop as Yield
Brian Weiss Apr 25, 2022

Finally, “Stop As Yield” (the much sought after common sense traffic law for bicyclists) is coming to Colorado in 2022, likely July 1st.   Stop as Yield, aka the “Safety Stop” After the Governor Polis signs the law and the Safety Stop becomes effective, anyone who rides a bicycle or scooter on public roads will […]

Read More
Contributory Negligence
Ann Groninger Apr 25, 2022

It took losing at trial and a long appellate process, but it ended in a blow to contributory negligence in North Carolina. We just won an appeal on a bicycle crash case that happened in 2016 and came to us in 2018. The case went to trial during the spring of 2021. Our client was […]

Read More
Load More