Call

Blog

Law
02

Blog

Security Cameras Prove Case

I will never forget the day that I was told that my unconscious client should have called 911.

Bob Mionske recently authored an article about cyclists using on-board cameras for Velo News.  This is the article that I direct folks to when they ask me about riding with a camera mounted. CNN recently published a piece about helmet cameras — in which Bike Law Peter was quoted.

On-board cameras have been getting a lot of attention. Here is a video clip which I used to establish liability in a recent hit and run out of Memphis.

The Memphis Hightailers and I have teamed up to collect footage and data of, among other things, instances of drivers violating the three-foot law in Tennessee. After an encounter on the roadway, members can go online and submit an incident report, which goes to my inbox. I’m certain that this footage will be very useful in the future.

Dear Hightailers, please keep the submissions coming. I do not think enough has been written on these topics, and I look forward to the continued discussion and data collection.

But this particular story involves a surveillance camera that caught a motorist when he thought he might get away with not reporting an accident! There was no on-board video from the cyclist to capture the driver’s behavior, but he still got caught. This is my client’s story, and I am honored to be the one to share it for her.

In the latter half of January, my client came to my office with a broken hand, separated shoulder, cuts, scrapes, bruises, and a blurry memory of exactly what happened in the minutes after the crash. This crash occurred on the north side of downtown Knoxville, just after midnight. My client was commuting 1.5 miles home from a birthday party.  She had proper lighting and she was riding on a signed city bicycle route with ample street lighting. A driver began a left-hand turn across my client’s traffic lane, and to avoid a collision, my client had to slam on her brakes. She crashed.

My client was doing everything right at the time of the crash, but this was still a tough set of facts. My client was riding her bike at night, there was no accident report, and no witnesses who saw the crash. The driver is a local news reporter, and may have wanted to avoid publicity. What he did not know, was that the whole thing was caught on camera.

I was troubled that with injuries as serious as the ones sustained by my client, and the possibility of a brain or spine injury which comes with any serious bike crash, she had not been placed on a backboard and transported from the scene by an ambulance. I was troubled that my client recalled the driver blaming her for the accident. I was troubled that the driver had not exchanged insurance information with my client.

But I contacted him directly and put his insurance carrier on notice of the claim. As expected, the adjustor called the same day, was hostile, accused my client of being reckless, and denied liability. I was determined to obtain justice for my client and educate the adjustor on cyclist rights.

At the time of the crash, my client was riding a recently refurbished 1999 mountain bike, valued at approximately $300.00. She did not have a camera mounted on her bicycle. After her crash, I had the same bike mechanic who had generously refurbished her bike free of charge back in December, examine the bicycle, which he determined to be beyond repair. (In a small world note, this mechanic is also friends with our own Bike Law Peter, having formerly lived in Charleston).

On the day we first met, my client alerted me to the fact that there may be surveillance video camera footage, and sure enough, a local business owner and downtown Knoxville resident had video cameras set up which caught the crash. Thanks to some quick work on the part of a bystander who determined who owned the buildings, and fed me that tip, I was able to schedule a meeting with the business owner and view the video on his cellular telephone. The business owner put me in touch with his security company, Safe N’ Sound, who promptly sent me two videos of the crash, one with a fixed lens, the other on a rotation. The video revealed that after curling up in pain for several minutes following the crash, my client lost consciousness five minutes into the ordeal. The driver does nothing; his body language reveals an attitude of being inconvenienced. It is upsetting to watch.

I sent the video footage to the insurance adjustor, and I figured that as soon as the extent of my client’s injuries were known, surely the case would resolve quickly. I was looking forward to the opportunity to educate and advocate for cyclists, armed with proof.

Once I knew my client’s prognosis and outlook, I sent a demand package over to the insurance adjustor, noting that my client’s pain and suffering damages were worsened as a result of the driver not immediately reporting the accident. The adjustor was indignant and angry that I had suggested that the driver needed to have reported the accident. She stated that my client was just fine and should have called 911 herself if she had wanted the accident reported.

I will never forget the day that I was told that my unconscious client should have called 911.

Surely this insurance adjustor couldn’t have watched the video in its entirety? I cited the specific Tennessee statutes which require at fault drivers to give immediate notice of an accident to authorities, exchange registration and insurance information in an accident, and create the duty to render aid in an accident, and asked that the insurance adjustor view the video in its entirety. I gave a one week deadline after which I would file suit.

I heard nothing.

I filed suit.

The first business day after I filed suit, I received a phone call from an insurance adjustor. The case had been reassigned shortly after the original adjustor and my telephone call. This new adjustor did ask about the well-being of my client, and we have since resolved the case amicably.

If a bike crash occurs in an area with businesses, there well may be video camera footage, even if there is not a camera mounted on the bike. Even with the video footage in this case, my client was subjected to further victimization by a hostile insurance adjustor.

It was an honor to be the protective shield between my client and the original misguided adjustor.

It was an honor to use my sword to obtain justice for my client. Cyclists should not have to face further victimization by insurance companies, and this was an egregious instance of just that.

I am sharing my client’s story because this all too common scenario has to change. Do not assume that if you have on-board video footage, that your case will be resolved without a fight. Shield yourself from any further victimization with representation.

We are not bicycle lawyers because the cases are easy; most of the time, they are anything but easy. We are bicycle lawyers because we are prepared to fight for cyclist’s rights. Our job is to make drivers and insurance adjustors understand cyclists will no longer allow themselves to be marginalized or blamed for exercising their right to travel.

I am happy to report that my client has recovered from her injuries, and is back to teaching her early morning yoga classes. I hope that she resumes bike commuting soon. I will be glad to ride alongside her.

Comments

Contributory Negligence
Ann Groninger Apr 08, 2021

There is finally a positive development in the fight against Contributory Negligence in North Carolina. Last week a bill called the “Victims’ Fair Treatment Act” was filed in the North Carolina Senate. If passed, the bill would finally bring North Carolina into line with all but 3 other states by eradicating this deeply unfair law. […]

Read More
Bike Shop with wheels
Danny Feldman Apr 04, 2021

Birmingham is blessed to have a number of great bike shops.  Two of these shops, although very different, are the focus here.  Future blog posts from Bike Law Alabama will focus on some of the other great shops in Birmingham and throughout Alabama. A NON-PROFIT BIKE SHOP: REDEMPTIVE CYCLES Why choose Redemptive as your Bike […]

Read More
Dooring of bicyclist
Charlie Thomas Mar 24, 2021

Buena Batiste did not plan to be “doored.” She was knocked off her bike by a car door and then yelled at by the woman who opened it. Fortunately, we were able to take Buena’s dooring case to trial and win. And in doing so, we set a new precedent for bicyclists who suffer a […]

Read More
Bike Hand Signals
Peter Wilborn Mar 12, 2021

Before you get a driver’s license, you typically have to take a test that demonstrates your understanding of the rules of the road. This includes the importance of signaling your intentions when you are turning or changing lanes. Across the United States, bicyclists are required to use signals to let others know what they plan […]

Read More
Ash Our Streets
Daniel Brazil Jan 13, 2021

As a Minneapolis-based attorney, I live, work, play and bike in the city. Although my city might be known for its lakes and our infamous Juicy Lucy, Minneapolis’ dedication to having safer streets for all should be included in that list. To reach the safe streets goal, numerous non-profit organizations and groups are working tirelessly […]

Read More
Ambassador
Rachael Maney Jan 11, 2021

Applications for the Bike Law Foundation Ambassador Program are now live. CLICK HERE FOR THE APPLICATION. The deadline to apply is Sunday, January 24th. Those selected will be notified on or before February 1. Thanks for your support and willingness to work together to make bicycling safer for all. We are committed to you, to one another, and […]

Read More
3-foot passing close call
Charlie Thomas Jan 11, 2021

It happens all the time: Someone emails me video footage, clearly showing they were biking along when a car buzzes past, coming within inches of a horrible crash — and there’s nothing I can do about it because we don’t have the laws in place to do something to help. Luckily, that might be about […]

Read More
killing cyclist bike law
Rachael Maney Dec 22, 2020

BIKE LAW ANNOUNCES THE INDICTMENT OF CARL BEHLER FOR KILLING CYCLIST AND INJURING OTHERS   Today, Carl Behler appeared in court for the first time for killing cyclist Arthur Carter and injuring others. He was indicted on Friday (12/18) by the Anne Arundel County Grand Jury and promptly arrested and detained for 7 crimes related […]

Read More
Bicycle Mayor
Bruce Hagen Dec 03, 2020

When I (Maria of Bike Law Georgia) called Pattie Baker, the first Metro Atlanta Bicycle Mayor, she was trudging through marshland on her bicycle on Alpharetta’s Big Creek Greenway. I pictured her in my mind with her bike, wearing her signature skirts, and mud on her sandals. Always on the go, the newly minted Metro […]

Read More
Load More