02

Blog

The Nation’s First Bike Share Fatality

The last few weeks of my job as a bike crash lawyer have been a mixture of both exhausting tragedy and a feeling of true purpose.

It’s been a brutal start to the summer for cyclists.  From New York to Michigan to San Fransisco and everywhere in between we’ve seen a level of carnage unmatched as far as I can remember.  I’ve been told that there are all sorts of possible reasons for these bike crashes, mostly some combination including more cars driving this season and more bicyclists on the road.  Personally, the last few weeks of my job as a bike crash lawyer have been a mixture of both exhausting tragedy and a feeling of true purpose.

This is the backdrop against which I write with a heavy heart about the first bike share fatality in the nation.  At approximately 9:00am Friday morning, 25 year old Virginia Murray was riding a Divvy bike share bicycle northbound on Sacramento Boulevard in Chicago.  As she approached the intersection of Belmont and Sacramento a flatbed truck, also northbound on Sacramento, made a right turn.  In the process of executing the right turn the truck struck Murray.  She is reported to have suffered a head trauma and was pronounced dead at 9:58am.

I was a huge supporter of bike shares before Chicago ever saw a Divvy.  I blogged for years about bike shares in places I visited, from the junky yellow bikes of Pensacola’s “bike share” run out of a local bar, to Paris’ Velib program.  All the while I longed for bike share to come to Chicago.  There were teaser programs long before Divvy.  There was talk about a “Blue Bike” program that might become a bike share, and there was the BCycle.  Those two programs didn’t amount to a mosquito bite compared to the growing rash of Divvy stations sprawling across our City.  When Divvy came to Chicago I was one of the first in line.  I was a founding member, having bought my membership the day they became available, well before the program’s launch.  I will never forget my first ride on a Divvy from Daley Plaza to Wicker Park along with some detours.  It was a murderous six miles.  I quickly learned that a Divvy is aptly suited for it’s intended purpose of short trips, and as such it is a wonderful compliment to the many other forms of transportation one might use in Chicago.

I have handled bicycle crash cases almost exclusively for over a decade now.  I’ve often said that when it comes to bike crash cases, “I’ve seen it all.”  That really isn’t true though because every case that every bicycle collision is unique and every collision poses unique problems and questions.  Bicycle cases have a special flare for unique problems as bicycle cases are often not as “black and white” as your run of the mill auto collision.  What I mean when I say, “I’ve seen it all,” is that bicycle cases have similar predictable themes.  These themes can be observed in similar types of collisions, and I’ve been doing this long enough that I know the types and their themes very well.

One thing I haven’t seen is a Divvy bicycle-share fatality.  We have handled a few cases in which Divvy bike-share users were involved in collisions, but we really haven’t seen too many dramatic injuries from those cases.  Just a few weeks ago I was quoted in a front page article in the Chicago Tribune about how safe bike shares are, and how they have not had so much as one fatality in the history of bike share programs in the United States.

So while the nation’s first bike-share death is something we haven’t seen before, I’ll say once again, “I’ve seen it all.”  I may not know exactly how this collision happened, but I bet I can predict some of the themes that will come out of it.

The collision that occurred between the truck and the Divvy was what we call, “the right hook.”  It is a very common collision.  In Chicago it is only outpaced in frequency by the “dooring” and the “left cross.”  A “right hook” occurs when a car and a cyclist are travelling in the same direction and a car makes a right turn into the path or person of the cyclist.  The typical scenario is that the driver passes the cyclist, then executes their turn.  In Chicago there is a statute that specifically prohibits the “right hook.”

The relevant portions read as follows:

9-16-020 (f)   Turning right in front of a bicycle.  When a motor vehicle and a bicycle are traveling in the same direction on any highway, street, or road, the operator of the motor vehicle overtaking such bicycle traveling on the right side of the roadway shall not turn to the right in front of the bicycle at that intersection or at any alley or driveway until such vehicle has overtaken and is safely clear of the bicycle.

After reading this you might think, “Well that means the Divvy collision today was the driver’s fault.”  I’d agree with you, but I expect the police and the company who owns the truck will not.  The media reports that no charges have yet been filed.  I will be surprised if any charges are filed against the driver.  I’ve seen a lot of “right hooks,”  but I’ve never seen a ticket issued for a “right hook.”  Further, I’ve never seen a defendant or insurance company take responsibility for their actions after “right hooking” a cyclist.  They tend to deny any liability.  In my experience the driver will usually claim that they signaled a right turn, and that they were in the process of executing their turn when the bicyclist attempted to pass them on the right.  They will use some permutation of the usual language drivers use to describe bicycle movements stating that, “…she came barreling down the street…  …came out of nowhere…” or “…rode up at a high rate of speed.”  I have a letter from an insurance company I use in my “Legal Cycling” presentations in which an insurance company denied a right hook claiming that their insured was stopped mid-turn when my client rode up at a high rate of speed and crashed his bicycle into the side of their insured’s truck.  “Right hooks” are one of the more highly contested bicycle cases in my experience.  I have yet to see one resolve voluntarily.

To add insult to injury, police often back the driver up.  In today’s case the report may hinge largely on what the driver says as the bicyclist will be unable to give her version of events.  The woman’s family may find themselves at the mercy of the Chicago Police to preserve evidence and witnesses.  As we saw recently with Blaine Klingenberg’s death, things aren’t always as simple as the police report would have you believe.

If my predictions come true anyone who has ridden a Divvy will know the fallacy of the driver’s story.  It lies in the assertion that a young woman on a Divvy bike is even capable of going fast.  Divvy bikes are slow and clunky by design.  They weigh 40lbs.  They only have a three speed hub.  You simply cannot go fast on a Divvy if your life depended on it.  Divvy’s aren’t designed to be fast.  They are designed to be sturdy, dependable and one-size-fits-all.  They are designed for short local trips, not for racing on a velodrome.

One of the beautiful things about the Divvy is that it’s design makes it somewhat safer than a regular bicycle.  Since it isn’t as fast one can’t really hot-rod a Divvy.  Further, you can’t miss a Divvy on the street.  They are painted a conspicuous bright pale blue, and they have built in front and rear lights that are always on.  Finally, the riding position of the Divvy is very high and upright, putting the rider at a good level to be seen by neighboring motorists.

The reality is that most right hooks occur when a driver overtakes a cyclist and they fail to notice the cyclist.  They execute their right turn without the faintest awareness of a bicycle to their side.  All cars are equpiied with a passenger side mirror.  There are no excuses.

When a motorist says, “The bicyclist came out of nowhere,”  I point out that there is no such thing as a magic cyclist.  Bicycles do not simply appear out of thin air.  The bicyclist was there, they just didn’t see her, and that is a error for which the driver should take responsibility.  Just because you were not looking for the cyclist doesn’t mean she wasn’t there.

While this is a sad day for the history of bike shares, I’d impress upon you that the bicycle really is a civilized and safe form of transportation.  Bike share transportation is statistically a very safe way to get around.  There have been something like 8 million trips taken by Divvy bike share members, and only one fatality.  If only car travel had such wonderful statistics.

Comments

Bruce Hagen Jul 17, 2018

On July 11, 2018, a very experienced rider and friend to many in the Rockdale County area, Albert “Ab” Roesel, was killed while out on a rural road doing a ride that he no doubt had done many times before.  Ab was 75 years old.   The police investigation concluded that Ab had been headed Southbound, […]

Read More
Brendan Kevenides Jun 04, 2018

At sea a boat under power must give way to a more vulnerable craft.  The law requires that a power driven vessel give way to a sailing vessel.  A sail boat must give way to a craft engaged in fishing. These simple rules are consistent with the maxim that with greater power comes greater responsibility. […]

Read More
Commuter Bike
Bruce Hagen May 29, 2018

Recently, my wife and I moved into a new home that’s closer to my office, which has allowed me to start commuting by bike.  I rode my bike to and from my office 4 consecutive days before my schedule forced me back into the car. My hope and plan is to commute by bike at […]

Read More
Pat Brown May 10, 2018

Strength, ambition, and courage are just a few words that come to mind when we think of Anthony Lue.  Growing up, Anthony enjoyed playing competitive sports such as baseball, volleyball, basketball and mountain biking, but his true passion was discovered on his high school track.    After winning gold for 100m hurdles at the provincial championships […]

Read More
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Apr 30, 2018

Following a horrific bicycle crash in 2016, Dr. Michael Rifkin has become a new type of bicycling advocate — one who is deeply committed to ending distracted driving. Read his op-ed on Making Distracted Driving in Maine Taboo here. Dr. Rifkin’s piece reminds us that we can be distracted by our phones and other electronic devices even […]

Read More
Brian Weiss Apr 26, 2018

On November 21, 2017, I saw a TV news story about how the Broomfield District Attorney’s Office was routinely offering lax plea deals to drivers that injure cyclists.  In bicycle crash cases with injuries, the DA was offering plead deals to “broken headlight” or “defective vehicle” charges. A “defective vehicle” sentence is one of the […]

Read More
Atlanta's Bike Czar
Bruce Hagen Apr 19, 2018

Who is looking for a great job in a dynamic city with a great opportunity to make bicycle advocacy not just a passion, but a full time, rewarding and well-paying job?   The City of Atlanta is in search of a a new Chief Bicycle Officer to replace the outgoing CBO, Superstar Becky Katz, who after […]

Read More
Joe Piscitello Apr 04, 2018

Piscitello Law – Bike Law PA is pleased to share highlights from the third annual Vision Zero conference, held March 17 in West Philadelphia.  The event was hosted by Philadelphia Bicycle Coalition and opening remarks by the Executive Director Sarah Clark Stuart encouraged 250 participants to “listen, learn and be inspired….”   Mayor James Kenney […]

Read More
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Apr 03, 2018

The first issue is that many bicycle crashes are not being reported into the State of Maine Crash Database, which leads to incomplete and inaccurate state-wide crash reporting data and arguably also leads to uninformed priority setting and budgetary decisions.  The crashes that are unreported and/or underreported on a state level are sometimes, but not […]

Read More
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Mar 25, 2018

Foundational Principles Bicycles are Traffic and Belong on Maine’s Roadways In Maine, bicycle riders are included within the definition of “traffic” and should be treated as part of Maine’s traffic system.  See 29-A M.R.S.A. § 101 (82).   Rights and Responsibilities In general, a person riding a bicycle in Maine has all of the rights […]

Read More
Joe Piscitello Mar 20, 2018

Vision Zero (VZ) is multi-nation initiative with a guiding principle that death and serious injury should not be an acceptable outcome of transportation.  Vision Zero plans often draw attention to flaws within the transportation system such as dangerous traffic patterns, speeding and a lack of sufficient protected bike/pedestrian lanes.  VZ action plans utilize data to […]

Read More
Danny Feldman Mar 15, 2018

I will not pretend to speak for all cyclists, but I feel pretty confident in saying that being passed by cars on the road is a primary area of concern. Most of the time there is no problem and the vehicle passes safely. Nevertheless, I personally have been “buzzed” more times than I wish were […]

Read More
Load More