02

Blog

Jury: Bicyclist not an “Obstruction”

Cyclist hit, cyclist injured, cyclist ticketed. Police wrong. Jury right!

He had just been launched skyward by the front end of a pickup truck.  Now the police were giving him a ticket.

Jason was riding his road bike in the travel lane of North River Road in Libertyville, Illinois with his father-in-law and two friends when an impatient teenaged driver in a Toyota Tacoma pulled behind the group.  The road had one southbound lane and one northbound lane divided by solid double yellow lines.  The shoulder of the narrow, rural road was a mix of dirt and loose gravel.  The T-intersection of River and Guerin Road was approaching, and Jason, leading the group, planned to make a left turn.  The young driver planned to pass.  The pickup truck, now traveling south in the northbound lane, zipped passed one, two, three bikers.  He reached Jason at the intersection and when Jason turned left he was met with the grill of the large vehicle.

Jason, a 41 year old married father of two young boys, and his riding companions, all in their 60s and 70s, were met at the scene with hostility from a responding police officer.  The driver had clearly broken the law, attempting to pass in an intersection after veering across double yellow lines.  But the officer’s focus was on Jason.  He and at least one of his companions confirmed that Jason signaled his intent to turn, but the officer chose not to believe them and issued Jason a traffic ticket.  The driver, whose parents rushed to the scene, received no citation.

Our Illinois bike law firm represented Jason.  The traffic ticket was dismissed when the officer declined to appear in court.  But the damage was done.  The way the police report was written combined with the issuance of the citation clearly influenced the way the driver’s insurance company, Allstate, viewed the case.  The driver and Allstate refused to compensate Jason, believing the collision was entirely his fault.  We filed a lawsuit.

The deposition testimony of the responding officer, a deputy with the Lake County Illinois Sheriff’s Police, provided some context for his decision making.  We elicited the following from him:

Q: Are you aware of any complaints from citizens in the area about bicyclists traveling on North River Road?

A: All the time.

Q: Tell me about that.  Prior to this crash how many such complaints were you aware of?

A: Every week we’d get complaints.  It could be on a daily basis.  Our command usually fields those phone calls and we’re given extra patrols to try to handle these complaints . . . . The complaints that we get are the bicyclists are either traveling too much in the roadway, not allowing vehicles to  pass, then causing traffic hazards, or that they are not stopping at stop signs, they’re making illegal turns, and the gambit runs on and on and on.  So bicyclists in District 2 in the county have been a very big, if you would, thorn in the side when it comes to warmer weather. . . . Unfortunately, they don’t want to follow by the same rules, unless we start to enforce them.  Once we start to enforce them, then it’s, you know, we’re picking on them.  So, yes, there’s been a very huge outcry of complaints of bicyclists in District 2 and specifically River Road.

* * * * *

Q: Were there ever any meetings or directives issued within the department about how to deal with this situation?

A: Sure.

Q: And what was discussed?

A: Write them.  Write them traffic tickets.

During his deposition, the officer said that he understood that there was nothing illegal per se about bicyclists riding on River Road.  He also admitted that the travel lane on River Road in the 100 yards or so north of Guerin provided the safest place of a cyclist to be, rather than on the gravel strewn shoulder.  He knew that double yellow lines mean no passing.  He understood that the Illinois Vehicle Code permits bicyclists to leave the right side of the roadway when preparing to make a left turn.

Why then did he ticket our client but not the teenaged driver?

The following passage from the officer’s deposition perhaps sheds some light onto how he views such situations:

Q: Do you feel that it was improper of the driver . . . to have attempted to pass the bicyclists across the double yellow line?

A: No.

Q: Why not?

A: It’s an everyday occurrence out there when you’re talking bicyclist.  If he comes over a hill and you’re moving – and the bicyclists are moving slower than what the posted speed limit is and you come over the hill and you now have this option to either run them over because, as you said, the lanes are substandard to fit both vehicles and bicyclists in it or to go around them, do the later part and go around them.

It should be noted that this was not a situation in which the driver’s move into the opposite lane was an evasive maneuver.  He had been behind the bicyclists for several seconds before deciding to pass.  They had simply been an obstacle in his way to get to where he wanted to go.

Through years of litigation the driver and his insurer refused to offer a dime of compensation to Jason and it became necessary to go to trial.  During the jury instructions conference with the judge the theme of bicyclist as roadway obstacle arose again.  At the conclusion of a jury trial, members of the jury are instructed, in writing, what the applicable law is and how they should apply the facts to the law to render a verdict for one side or the other.  During the conference it was suggested that the jury be allowed to consider whether a bicyclist is a roadway obstruction.  Section 11-701 of the Illinois Vehicle Code states:

Upon all roadways of sufficient width a vehicle shall be driven upon the right half of the roadway, except as follows:

  1. When overtaking and passing another vehicle proceeding in the same direction under the rules governing such movements;
  1. When an obstruction exists making it necessary to drive to the left of the center of the roadway.

The implication was that if the jury felt that Jason was an “obstruction” then the law allowed the driver to cross the double yellow line to pass.

I vehemently opposed such an instruction.  A bicyclist — certainly not an adult riding where he was legally permitted to be – could never be labeled an obstruction.  The word obstruction is not defined in the vehicle code nor is there any Illinois case law defining it.  But surely a legal road user could not be that.  An obstruction is a fallen log, a deer carcass, a disabled car; not a vehicle simply going slower than the driver behind him preferred.  The judge, however, was unpersuaded and allowed the jury to be instructed that if they felt Jason was an obstruction then the defendant did not violate the ban on solid line crossing.

The jury did not buy it!

In the end we won the trial, the jurors finding that the driver was mostly at fault for causing the crash.  They did assign some fault to Jason, 30% versus 70% for the driver.  We were not permitted to interview jurors after the trial’s conclusion, but it seems that they did not think that Jason signaled, or perhaps did not signal sufficiently.  But we were heartened that the attitude expressed by the police officer was rejected and the Court’s invitation to label a bicyclist an obstruction did not carry the day.

Comments

Rachael Maney Nov 28, 2018

I asked my 7 year old son, Will, to draw me a picture of each of these things: life with cars; life with electric cars; life with autonomous cars; they all looked the same. But the fourth picture- life in a modern, forward thinking, and environmentally, economically, and socially responsible place- looked very different. Even […]

Read More
Matt Johnson Nov 06, 2018

We were somewhere around Denison on the edge of the corn fields when the Eurostyle Chamois Butter began to take hold. I remember saying something like “I feel a bit lightheaded, maybe we should stop at a watering station…” And suddenly there was a terrible roar all around us, and the road was full of […]

Read More
Peter Wilborn Oct 02, 2018

October is a big month in the triathlon world, with the Kona Ironman World Championships on the 13th. So it is good news that Triathlete Magazine chose its October issue to focus on bicycle safety and advocacy. Bike Law Director (and our resident triathlete) Rachael Maney was featured and interviewed in the piece. She shared […]

Read More
Peter Wilborn Sep 28, 2018

Chicago has become one of the nation’s top cycling cities, but along with more has come an increase in dooring crashes. A Chicago news channel has covered the issue and interviewed attorney Brendan Kevenides, Bike Law’s legal resource in Illinois. Brendan explained the growing risk to cyclists and how the “Dutch Reach” can help.  The […]

Read More
Amy Benner Johnson Sep 21, 2018

Drivers are coming within less than 1.5 feet of cyclists on the road in Knoxville with alarming regularity. Drivers are coming within less than two feet of cyclists on the road in Knoxville with alarming regularity. It’s not your imagination. It’s not all in your head. Your combined senses of touch, sound, and sight all […]

Read More
Rachael Maney Sep 12, 2018

You may have already seen the video below. If you haven’t, please watch. On Tuesday, August 24th just before 7PM, Jeff McCord and approximately 20 other cyclists were stopped at the intersection of Karl Daly and Grants Mill Road in Irondale, Alabama, a town outside the city of Birmingham. As McCord waited for an ambulance […]

Read More
Rachael Maney Aug 30, 2018

In 2010, Richmond, California got lucky when Brooklyn born Najari Smith planted roots in the Bay Area city, quickly claiming a very important role in his new community. Having given more than 1,100 bikes to Richmond’s youth and community members in the last 6 years, Najari’s vision and mission to promote a bike-centric lifestyle has […]

Read More
Bruce Hagen Jul 17, 2018

On July 11, 2018, a very experienced rider and friend to many in the Rockdale County area, Albert “Ab” Roesel, was killed while out on a rural road doing a ride that he no doubt had done many times before.  Ab was 75 years old.   The police investigation concluded that Ab had been headed Southbound, […]

Read More
Brendan Kevenides Jun 04, 2018

At sea a boat under power must give way to a more vulnerable craft.  The law requires that a power driven vessel give way to a sailing vessel.  A sail boat must give way to a craft engaged in fishing. These simple rules are consistent with the maxim that with greater power comes greater responsibility. […]

Read More
Commuter Bike
Bruce Hagen May 29, 2018

Recently, my wife and I moved into a new home that’s closer to my office, which has allowed me to start commuting by bike.  I rode my bike to and from my office 4 consecutive days before my schedule forced me back into the car. My hope and plan is to commute by bike at […]

Read More
Pat Brown May 10, 2018

Strength, ambition, and courage are just a few words that come to mind when we think of Anthony Lue.  Growing up, Anthony enjoyed playing competitive sports such as baseball, volleyball, basketball and mountain biking, but his true passion was discovered on his high school track.    After winning gold for 100m hurdles at the provincial championships […]

Read More
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Apr 30, 2018

Following a horrific bicycle crash in 2016, Dr. Michael Rifkin has become a new type of bicycling advocate — one who is deeply committed to ending distracted driving. Read his op-ed on Making Distracted Driving in Maine Taboo here. Dr. Rifkin’s piece reminds us that we can be distracted by our phones and other electronic devices even […]

Read More
Load More