02

Blog

A Cautionary Tale on Proper Bicycle Crash Reporting

Imagine waking up in a nightmare scenario - you’ve been hit by a car, treated at an emergency room, and are being discharged to find that you have no information about the driver that injured you. Worse, you learn that the responding police officers failed to write a report. Now, you are faced with medical bills, a damaged bike, and lots of pain, without any path to recovery.

Recently, Elyse Bejasa rode down the bike lane on St. Charles Avenue in New Orleans. Near the intersection with State Street, the driver’s door of a parked car opened suddenly into her path. Without any time to react, Elyse crashed into the door and was thrown over her handlebars. She landed violently – jaw-first – onto the pavement.

After EMS responded to provide medical care, officers from the New Orleans Police Department also responded to investigate the crash.

What happened next made this wreck become blog-worthy as a cautionary tale. As Elyse was loaded into the ambulance and headed to an emergency room, the responding police officer spoke with the driver who caused the crash. The driver told the officer that she and the bicyclist would plan to handle the crash “civilly” and that a police report was unnecessary. The driver was then allowed to leave the scene. Simultaneously, the officer did not speak with Elyse about this non-reporting issue and ultimately departed the scene without making a written record of the crash.

In doing so, the police officer violated state law by not preparing a report with an injury. Under the law of many states, including Louisiana, a responding police officer must investigate crashes that involve injury to any person or property damage in excess of five hundred dollars shall. La. Stat. Ann. § 32:398. Furthermore, any investigating police officer shall instruct the driver of each vehicle involved in the crash to give the other people involved their (i) name and contact info; (ii) license number; and (iii) insurance information. Upon completing the investigation, the investigating officer must then forward a copy of any such report to the State Department of Public Safety.

Crash reporting is important for several reasons

According to Tara Tolford, who studies crash data at the UNO Transportation Institute, this information is vital for improving roadway injuries:

“Crash report data is one of the most valuable tools planners and engineers use to identify safety issues, investigate patterns, and advocate for infrastructure investment.”

Increasingly, we need objective, quantitative data to convince decision-makers that a change is needed, to apply for funding, and to evaluate whether a project was successful–anecdotes and ‘gut feelings’ aren’t enough. The more complete, detailed, and accurate the crash data is, the better. Even if an individual incident is relatively minor, it may be part of a trend of similar incidents that reflect a deficiency in the built environment that we can correct before a more serious crash occurs.

Yet in addition to this industry best practice, remember that crash reporting is so important that state law requires it.

What did we do to help?

Unfortunately, responding police officers don’t always adhere to this requirement. For Elyse, we got down to business before too much evidence went stale. We first contacted the District for the New Orleans Police Department where the crash occurred. After expressing our concerns about spoiled evidence to the commanding officer, we were able to identify which police officer responded to the crash scene. We next tracked down that officer, who confirmed that she had not prepared a report for our crash. We raised our concerns about Elyse’s inability to recover without the information of the adverse driver, as well as that the failure to prepare a report violated state law.

The officer, who was not acquainted with this legal requirement, read the law and ultimately changed her mind. She apologized for not initially preparing a report and was able to retrieve her body camera footage that captured the identity of the adverse driver. Fortunately, this information was still available. The officer prepared a report and cited the adverse driver for failing to exercise reasonable vigilance, which helped us to recover the insurance policy limits to compensate Elyse for her losses. Nevertheless, a different series of events could have resulted in the inability to identify this driver and Elyse not having any recovery.

Let this occurrence serve as a caution to riders finding themselves in this situation to insist that a report is prepared, both for their own circumstances as well as for the larger importance of crash data reporting.  

Educating Local Law Enforcement

In cities and states across the country, we are working with law enforcement officers to update training and outreach. Police need to be aware of the laws that are intended to protect cyclists and enforce them. If you or someone you know is in a bicycle crash, make sure there is a proper report. A crash report that avoids victim blaming and provides all parties, and local planners, with the information they need.

Photo Credit: The Maroon

Comments

Bike Law RAAM Team
Arleigh Jenkins Jun 19, 2017

2 days ago our RAAM team’s started journey began. Make sure to track their progress!

Read More
2017 Bike Law Michigan Bicycle Tour
Bryan Waldman Jun 08, 2017

Tales and tips on doing your own self-guided tour through Michigan leaving right from your own driveway.

Read More
Bicycle Dooring Education
Brendan Kevenides Jun 01, 2017

The urban bicyclist rides in perpetual fear of having a door flung open into their path. Sadly, the number of such incidents is going in the wrong direction.

Read More
Bike Law Canada - Martin Goodman Trail Toronto
Pat Brown May 31, 2017

This may seem to be about a basic barrier on the side of a path but this fight is to ensure our children and all vulnerable road users have safe roads or paths to ride on.

Read More
Toronto Youth Biking Death
Pat Brown May 25, 2017

How many tragedies do we need in Toronto before we invest in keeping Vulnerable Road Users safe?

Read More
Cycling Law Podcast
Arleigh Jenkins May 23, 2017

Ann Groninger of Bike Law NC & Jeff Viscount of Weekly Rides have become regulars on the TotalCyclist Podcast. Click through to give a listen to their episodes!

Read More
biking on highway laws in texas
Arleigh Jenkins May 17, 2017

Charlie answers a frequently asked question whether one may legally ride a bicycle on highway Interstate 10 and other freeways in Texas.

Read More
2017 Ride of Silence
Arleigh Jenkins May 15, 2017

A guest post from Chris Phelan, founder of Ride for Silence. This ride can be found in 450+ cities across the world on May 17th to honor those who have been injured or killed, to raise awareness that we are here and to ask that we all share the road.

Read More
Charlotte Law Enforcement Bicycle Ride to DC
Ann Groninger May 10, 2017

Yesterday, Bike Law Cycle Club members Julia Engle and Garet Johnson joined the first leg of CMPD’s Annual Law Enforcement Bicycle Ride to Washington D.C.

Read More
Maine Traffic Safety Education Bill
Lauri Boxer-Macomber May 03, 2017

In Maine, proposed legislation on traffic safety education in schools for students in grades 2-12 could have tremendous long-term effects on making Maine’s roads safer.

Read More
NY Five Boro Bike Ride
Daniel Flanzig May 03, 2017

Bike Law New York is entering its 4th year of supporting the TD Five Boro Bike Tour, the world’s largest charity ride with over 32,000 riders. Riding? Stop by to say hello.

Read More
Michigan Needs Better Cycling Laws
Bryan Waldman May 02, 2017

I am outraged when I see motorists that kill bicyclists charged with only minor crimes. It is time we stopped looking to blame others for this lack of accountability and look for solutions.

Read More
Load More