02

Blog

Investigating the Police Chase That Caused a Bicycle Fatality in Atlanta

Andrew Whitlock was killed on November 6, 2017, while riding his bike. He was 37 years old. His killer was driving a station wagon and was fleeing from police who had attempted to stop him for questioning due to his “suspicious behavior,” according to news reports on the subject.

The person who killed Andrew Whitlock abandoned the car he was driving and fled the scene on foot. He has not, as of the time this article, been identified or caught. The area of this occurrence is surrounded by buildings with security cameras that may offer help in identifying the driver. We’re hoping that the driver will be brought to justice swiftly and that he will be held fully accountable for his brutal and callous actions that caused the death of an innocent member of the Atlanta cycling community.

Investigating the Circumstances of a Police Chase

Beyond just bringing the driver to justice, however, there needs to be a thorough investigation into the underlying circumstances that led to the driver fleeing the police in the first place. Georgia law imposes strict rules on police chases that, if not adhered to, can result in liability of the police officer and department for the damages that are caused to innocent bystanders. The basic analysis can be simplified this way: the police officer’s vehicle is a gun, the fleeing vehicle is a bullet that was fired out of the gun. If the gun was discharged properly, then there’s no liability for where the bullet lands. If the gun was discharged improperly or recklessly, then the shooter is responsible for the damage caused by the bullet.

One of the ways to analyze the situation is to measure the relative potential for harm that the driver presents to the public at large. For example, an armed robbery suspect who fired a gun in the course of his getaway and is driving away from the crime scene presents an imminent threat to the general public, whereas a driver who simply rolled through a stop sign does not present the same threat. A high-speed chase may be justified in the first instance but certainly not in the second.

At this point, there’s been no information released to the public that would indicate any improper actions on the part of the APD officers that were involved. Still, in the interest of being thorough, we should all hope that the investigation is going beyond just trying to apprehend the missing driver and is analyzing every aspect of the underlying events that led to his flight from the officers.

Like most police departments, City of Atlanta PD has a protocol that sets out department guidelines for pursuing motor vehicles. You can see the specifics here. Whether the officers in Andrew Whitlock’s case complied with the guidelines should be part of the inquiry into the circumstances surrounding his death.

One of the tricky things, of course, is that the investigation into the underlying circumstances of the event is generally being conducted by members of the same police department that ultimately could be deemed to have some responsibility for the damage done. Accordingly, it can often be useful to have an independent investigation into the facts to avoid any concern over a potential conflict of interest.

None of this is intended to say that the heartless actions of the hit & run driver who left Andrew Whitlock dead in the street shouldn’t be held accountable for his actions. But if the underlying pursuit of the driver should never have occurred in the first place, then that driver is not alone in being responsible for Andrew Whitlock’s death. Andrew’s family, at the very least, deserves answers to these questions.

Featured Photo Credit: BikeFriendlyATL

Comments

Biking After COVID 5
Ann Groninger May 28, 2020

What will biking after COVID be like? Before COVID, it seemed like there was a handful of people in my city who rode bikes to get places, and we all knew each other. We’ve always had a robust recreational road riding community of people who gather after work and on weekends to head out to […]

Read More
Bike Advocate
Bruce Hagen May 26, 2020

If you’ve ridden a bike anywhere in Atlanta, chances are you’ve met Atlanta bike advocate Angel Poventud.  If you’ve stopped for a post-ride beer, been to an important advocacy event, or to any major Atlanta gathering, chances are you have met Angel Poventud.   It may only seem that Angel is everywhere, but when you […]

Read More
Bicycle accident lawyer group riding in COVID
Kurt Holzer May 15, 2020

Idaho’s Governor Little has issued the State’s planned staged transition away from his Stay-at-Home health order.  Road cyclists continue to wonder how we should engage in group riding under COVID. As a bicycle accident lawyer who deals with the negative aspects of cycling, I have been thinking a lot about when and how to ride safely […]

Read More
Felix Mayer Cyclist killed by car. NO VRU law
Bruce Hagen Apr 30, 2020

On May 1, 2020, the City of Dunwoody’s new Vulnerable Road User (“VRU”) ordinance will take effect, the first such law to be enacted anywhere in the State of Georgia.  Hopefully neighboring municipalities like Sandy Springs, Roswell and Chamblee will follow suit, and more importantly, the State of Georgia.   VRU laws recognize and prioritize […]

Read More
Minnesota Cycling
Daniel Brazil Apr 23, 2020

On March 6, Minneapolis released a 252-page Transportation Action Plan. The plan’s ultimate goal is to expand transportation options for those walking, biking and taking public transit to get where they need to go.  Through this expansion, Minneapolis hopes to reduce the number of vehicles on the road, lowering greenhouse gas emissions. One of the […]

Read More
Bike to Work Corona
Daniel Brazil Apr 14, 2020

Not long ago, I published a post highlighting the great efforts being made by the co-chairs of the Saint Paul Bicycle Coalition. One of the co-chairs, Andy Singer, has garnered attention not just for his work for the Coalition but for his policy-based cartoons.  I asked Andy if he’d oblige to another interview to highlight […]

Read More
Load More