02

Blog

The Liability for Failing to Maintain a Bike Path

How much protection do Illinois municipalities have from liability for failing to maintain a dangerous bicycle path?

In a decision handed down last week, the Illinois Supreme Court held that cities and towns in our state have quite a lot of protection.  However, overturning a 1996 decision by the Illinois appellate court, the Supreme Court ruled that that protection is not limitless.

In Corbett v. The County of Lake, 2017 IL 121536, the Court held that the City of Highland Park did not have blanket immunity for its failure to maintain the Skokie Valley Bike Path where the allegedly poor condition of the path caused serious injury to a bicyclist.  Its decision reversed the trial court’s dismissal of the case. The issue was whether Section 3-107(b) of the Local Governmental and Governmental Employees Tort Immunity Act applied to free Highland Park from responsibility for negligently and even willfully and wantonly maintaining (or failing to maintain) the Path.  That Section provides, in relevant part that: Neither a local public entity nor a public employee is liable for an injury caused by a condition of : * * * (b) Any hiking, riding, fishing or hunting trail. 745 ILCS 10/3-107(b).

The injured bicyclist, Kathy Corbett, was injured while riding with friends on the Skokie Valley Bike Path in Highland Park when she was thrown from her bike “while riding over the defective portion of the path.”  Highland Park argued that because the incident occurred while Ms. Corbett was on a “riding trail,” it could not be held liable for her injuries pursuant to Section 3-107(b).  The trial court agreed and dismissed Ms. Corbett’s case.  She appealed and the Illinois Second District Court of Appeals reversed the lower court citing an earlier decision in Brown v. Cook County Forest Preserve, 284 Ill.App.3d 1098 (1st Dist. 1996).  In Brown, the appellate court held that Section 3-107(b) applied only to trails winding through forests and/or mountainous regions.  This time the City appealed.  The Supreme Court upheld the appellate court’s reversal, but used an entirely different approach and expressly overturned Brown.  The Supreme Court held that it mattered not whether the trail or path ran through a forest or mountains.  (FYI:  Illinois = no mountains).  Instead, given its grouping with “hiking,” “fishing,” and “hunting,” the term “riding trail, as used in Section 3-107(b), was meant “to apply blanket immunity only to primitive, rustic, or unimproved trails.”  Since the Skokie Valley Bike Path was paved and “runs through a busy, developed commercial and industrial area” it did not fit that description, and blanket immunity could not apply.

Since the Court’s ruling on November 30th, I have heard from bicycle advocates who have expressed concern that municipalities may be disinclined to install bike paths for fear of being held liable should an injury occur.  This concern is not warrantless.  In the past, city leaders in Illinois have expressed reticence at building bicycle specific infrastructure without a guarantee of absolute immunity from liability.  The Corbett decision need not, however, provoke much worry among municipal leaders.  Cities and towns in Illinois are still afforded quite a lot of protection from litigation.  The Corbett Court expressly held that a different section of Illinois’s Tort Immunity Statute, 745 ILCS 10/3-106, would apply providing immunity from all but willful and wanton conduct.  This is a high bar.  An injured person would need to prove that in causing their injury, a municipality acted with a deliberate intent to harm, or demonstrated “an utter indifference to or conscious disregard for the safety of others.”  Illinois Pattern Jury Instruction 14.01.  Negligence is not enough.  This, plus the requirement that a plaintiff demonstrates that a municipality had notice of the dangerous condition, provides substantial protection to municipalities.  Citing Corbett as a reason for not building bike trails, should be viewed as pretense or a misunderstanding the protections still provided under Illinois law.  The Corbett Court considered the City’s argument that shooting down blanket immunity would discourage the building of bike paths.  The Court stated that, “It seems strange to say that a local public entity can build and maintain a bike trail, encourage people to use it, and represent that it is safe but then escape all liability for injuries caused by even the most egregious misconduct in failing to maintain it.”

If you see something, say something

How does one show a “conscious disregard for the safety of others?” By demonstrating that a municipality knew that a trial condition, i.e., a large pothole, existed, that it posed a danger to people on bikes, yet failed to do anything about it. So, if you see something, say something. Report dangerous trail conditions when you see them. Be as specific as possible. Hopefully, the problem is fixed. But if it is not, and someone gets hurt, at least there will be a record showing that the municipality knew about it yet failed to act.

Brendan Kevenides is a bicycle crash attorney in Chicago, IL with Freeman Kevenides Law Firm and represents Bike Law Illinois. He is a certified bicycle instructor by the League of American Bicyclists (LCI #3732), a member of the Chicago Cycling Club’s steering committee and a member of the Active Transportation Alliance’s advisory committee. He is a regular rider during Critical Mass, The Chicago Ride of Silence and other popular cycling events.

Comments

Amy Benner Johnson Sep 21, 2018

Drivers are coming within less than 1.5 feet of cyclists on the road in Knoxville with alarming regularity. Drivers are coming within less than two feet of cyclists on the road in Knoxville with alarming regularity. It’s not your imagination. It’s not all in your head. Your combined senses of touch, sound, and sight all […]

Read More
Rachael Maney Sep 12, 2018

You may have already seen the video below. If you haven’t, please watch. On Tuesday, August 24th just before 7PM, Jeff McCord and approximately 20 other cyclists were stopped at the intersection of Karl Daly and Grants Mill Road in Irondale, Alabama, a town outside the city of Birmingham. As McCord waited for an ambulance […]

Read More
Rachael Maney Aug 30, 2018

In 2010, Richmond, California got lucky when Brooklyn born Najari Smith planted roots in the Bay Area city, quickly claiming a very important role in his new community. Having given more than 1,100 bikes to Richmond’s youth and community members in the last 6 years, Najari’s vision and mission to promote a bike-centric lifestyle has […]

Read More
Bruce Hagen Jul 17, 2018

On July 11, 2018, a very experienced rider and friend to many in the Rockdale County area, Albert “Ab” Roesel, was killed while out on a rural road doing a ride that he no doubt had done many times before.  Ab was 75 years old.   The police investigation concluded that Ab had been headed Southbound, […]

Read More
Brendan Kevenides Jun 04, 2018

At sea a boat under power must give way to a more vulnerable craft.  The law requires that a power driven vessel give way to a sailing vessel.  A sail boat must give way to a craft engaged in fishing. These simple rules are consistent with the maxim that with greater power comes greater responsibility. […]

Read More
Commuter Bike
Bruce Hagen May 29, 2018

Recently, my wife and I moved into a new home that’s closer to my office, which has allowed me to start commuting by bike.  I rode my bike to and from my office 4 consecutive days before my schedule forced me back into the car. My hope and plan is to commute by bike at […]

Read More
Pat Brown May 10, 2018

Strength, ambition, and courage are just a few words that come to mind when we think of Anthony Lue.  Growing up, Anthony enjoyed playing competitive sports such as baseball, volleyball, basketball and mountain biking, but his true passion was discovered on his high school track.    After winning gold for 100m hurdles at the provincial championships […]

Read More
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Apr 30, 2018

Following a horrific bicycle crash in 2016, Dr. Michael Rifkin has become a new type of bicycling advocate — one who is deeply committed to ending distracted driving. Read his op-ed on Making Distracted Driving in Maine Taboo here. Dr. Rifkin’s piece reminds us that we can be distracted by our phones and other electronic devices even […]

Read More
Brian Weiss Apr 26, 2018

On November 21, 2017, I saw a TV news story about how the Broomfield District Attorney’s Office was routinely offering lax plea deals to drivers that injure cyclists.  In bicycle crash cases with injuries, the DA was offering plead deals to “broken headlight” or “defective vehicle” charges. A “defective vehicle” sentence is one of the […]

Read More
Atlanta's Bike Czar
Bruce Hagen Apr 19, 2018

Who is looking for a great job in a dynamic city with a great opportunity to make bicycle advocacy not just a passion, but a full time, rewarding and well-paying job?   The City of Atlanta is in search of a a new Chief Bicycle Officer to replace the outgoing CBO, Superstar Becky Katz, who after […]

Read More
Joe Piscitello Apr 04, 2018

Piscitello Law – Bike Law PA is pleased to share highlights from the third annual Vision Zero conference, held March 17 in West Philadelphia.  The event was hosted by Philadelphia Bicycle Coalition and opening remarks by the Executive Director Sarah Clark Stuart encouraged 250 participants to “listen, learn and be inspired….”   Mayor James Kenney […]

Read More
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Apr 03, 2018

The first issue is that many bicycle crashes are not being reported into the State of Maine Crash Database, which leads to incomplete and inaccurate state-wide crash reporting data and arguably also leads to uninformed priority setting and budgetary decisions.  The crashes that are unreported and/or underreported on a state level are sometimes, but not […]

Read More
Load More