02

Blog

Mandatory bicycle helmet laws are a terrible idea

The safety solution is more people on bikes, not fewer.

A federal government agency is making a controversial recommendation to all 50 states that all bicyclists be required to wear helmets.  

Mandatory bicycle helmet laws are a terrible idea.  Cycling as a form of recreation and transportation offers a myriad of benefits to the individual and the community as a whole.  An adult or child riding a bike to work or school takes one motor vehicle off the road thereby reducing traffic congestion and pollution.  It also reduces the strain on mass transit.  Buses and trains are less crowded and more pleasant to ride.  Also, motor vehicles place a physical strain on infrastructure that a much lighter bicycle does not.  Bicycle trips save the community money by taking heavy cars and trucks off the road.  In this age of rampant obesity, cycling helps promote good health.  This too saves the community money by reducing expenditure for health benefits such as Medicaid, particularly with regard to treatment for ailments closely associated with obesity like diabetes and heart disease.

These benefits are placed at substantial risk by helmet laws, because such mandates discourage higher rates of biking.  This very concern prompted the City of Dallas, Texas to repeal its adult bicycle helmet ordinance in 2014.  That city wanted to see more cyclists on its roads through a bike share system.  However, civic leaders recognized that such a program would likely be doomed to failure if casual bikers were required to fetch a helmet in order to rent a bike.  Australia is one country that requires all adults to wear helmets when cycling.  The impact has been unfortunate. According to the Institute for Public Affairs, an Australian think tank, “When the laws were introduced in the early 1990s, cycling trips declined by 30-40 per cent overall, and up to 80 per cent in some demographic groups, such as secondary school-aged females.”

If the goal is to reduce the likelihood of serious injury for the individual bicyclist, then helmet mandates are the wrong way to go.  Yes, wearing a helmet while biking is safer than not doing so.  But the factor most likely to reduce the likelihood of bicycle versus motor vehicle collision is to increase the number of riders on the road.  More people on bikes means motorists are more likely to anticipate a bicyclist when turning or opening a car door.  More bicyclists also encourages municipalities to invest in bicycle specific infrastructure like protected bike lanes, and to keep them in good repair.  Understandably, city officials are less likely to push for such measures if they do not think people will use them in substantial numbers.

Laws that require helmet use can also have a devastating impact on a cyclist’s ability to receive just compensation should they be injured due to someone else’s negligence.  The way some laws are written, failure to obey a helmet requirement could be used against a bicyclist in personal injury litigation as evidence of their own negligence, even if failure to wear a helmet had nothing to do with how or why the crash happened.  (But see, for example, Deerfield, Illinois municipal code Sec. 22-121A(c) which states, “A violation of this Section shall not constitute negligence, contributory negligence, assumption of risk, be considered in mitigation of damages of whatever nature, be admissible in evidence, or be the subject of comment by counsel in any action for the recovery of damages arising out of the operation of any bicycle.”)

Bike Law is not anti-bicycle helmet. But legislation requiring helmets are a bad idea.

Comments

Bike Law Georgia
Bruce Hagen Feb 23, 2020

When we’re not busy helping injured cyclists with their bike accident claims, we at Bike Law Georgia love to spend our time helping to make the world a better place for everyone who enjoys riding on bikes. We are honored to join the collective efforts of fellow advocacy groups, organizations, cycling clubs and individuals in […]

Read More
TSA Bike Gear
Charlie Thomas Feb 14, 2020

If you ever leave a bike trip and land in a TSA interview room because of your stowaway bike accessory, reading this blog first may help. On bike rides, I try to never leave home without a CO2 cartridge just in case I get a flat. I recently worked my way through a Transportation Security […]

Read More
Biking with Kids
Amy Benner Johnson Feb 14, 2020

The annual Tennessee Bike Summit is being held April 16-17, 2020. The summit is in Cleveland, Tennessee for the first time ever this year, so I chatted with Gina Simpson, the head of Bike Walk Cleveland to learn more  Q : As a Tennessee bike accident attorney, I am familiar with you because I serve […]

Read More
Timmy Finch Feb 12, 2020

One of the simplest, yet most important, ideas that we as cycling advocates try to convey to drivers is that people riding bikes on the roads are actual people with lives and identities apart from just “cyclist.” They are people on bikes. They are wives, husbands, daughters cousins, and uncles, for example. They are also […]

Read More
Distracted Driving
Timmy Finch Feb 10, 2020

As a bicycle crash attorney, I spend a lot of time thinking of ways to prevent bike crashes. As a cyclist who rides almost everywhere I go for all of my daily errands, it is personal to me as well. Many people say that education is the key. Awareness of cycling laws should be part […]

Read More
Arrested Florida Cyclist
Rachael Maney Feb 09, 2020

Tuesday, February 11, 2020, 11:45 a.m. Here’s the Dash Cam and Body Cam video of exactly what happened. Here’s the Dash Cam: And here’s the Body Cam:   Complete videos on the Bike Law Youtube Channel. Monday, February 10, 2020, 2:30 p.m. I decided to give a statement to Channel 6 today because the Lopez […]

Read More
Load More