Call

Blog

Law
02

Blog

Contributory Negligence: A Rare Victory in NC

It took losing at trial and a long appellate process, but it ended in a blow to contributory negligence in North Carolina. We just won an appeal on a bicycle crash case that happened in 2016 and came to us in 2018. The case went to trial during the spring of 2021. Our client was riding her bicycle straight through a greenlight when she was hit by an oncoming car turning left in the intersection. We lost the trial because the jury found our client contributorily negligent. We immediately appealed.

On April 19, 2022, we won the appeal. It is still left to be determined the value of the damages our client suffered, so there is potentially another jury trial to come on that issue.

 

Contributory Negligence

The issue on appeal will be no surprise to those familiar with my rantings about North Carolina law: contributory negligence. If you’re new to this forum, contributory negligence (aka “pure contributory negligence” or “contrib”) is a legal doctrine in only four states: NC, VA, MD and AL (all Bike Law states). If an injured person brings a case against someone else for their injuries, a judge or jury must decide if the injured person “contributed to his or her own injury.”

A jury would have to answer this question in any case, in any state. What is different about North Carolina is that if the answer is “Yes,” then that is the end of the story and the injured person gets nothing. In other states, if the injured person is 1% at fault, then they get 99% of their damages; a much more fair result.

 

Contributory Negligence is Unfair to Cyclists

Why is contributory negligence so bad for bicyclists? We have tried dozens of cases, and conducted even more focus groups, in bicycle cases. Almost universally, non-bicyclist lay people (and even some bicyclists) believe that someone riding a bicycle must have some fault in a crash, even if they are following all the rules and being careful. It takes a lot (including an experienced bicycle attorney) to overcome contributory negligence and it makes resolving cases early, and for reasonable amounts, much harder than it should be. Jury trials are, likewise, riskier than they should be.

 

The Klapp Case

The story in this case went like this: the bicyclist, Julie Klapp, was out for her regularly early morning bike ride. Like many of us in the Charlotte area, she rode early to avoid heavy traffic. She had all the lighting required by law and had researched lighting choices to make sure she found something that made her suitably visible to motorists on the road at that time of the morning.

Near the end of her ride, Julie approached a traffic light. The light was red as she rode up the hill toward it. She prepared to slow down and unclip. As she got closer to the light, it turned green and she began to pedal again. When she got to the intersection, she saw a driver preparing to turn left. The driver had his signal on and was waiting in the intersection. Watching the driver, Julie continued to move forward. Once Julie was already in the intersection, the driver suddenly made the turn and broadsided Julie. He hit the left side of her body, injuring her.

Defense Use (Misuse) of Contributory Negligence

What was the contributory negligence defense? That she saw the defendant in the intersection, waiting to turn, and shouldn’t have proceeded. Imagine what that would look like, if everyone on the road stopped before an intersection where a driver was positioned to turn left. It would be chaos! When on the road, bicyclists are supposed to follow the rules of the road; it is the law and it makes sense. Julie did just that.

Attorney Helen Baddour tried this case for our firm. At every step of the way, Helen tried, unsuccessfully, to get the judge to intervene in striking the defense’s contributory negligence defense. But we still thought that there was no way the jury would find that Julie contributed to the crash.

Unfortunately, they did. Although they found the driver at fault, because they also found Julie at fault, the discussion ended there and the verdict was $0. The jury is not required to assign a particular percentage to fault, so we don’t know whether that was discussed or not.

 

Our Victory Over Contributory Negligence

The decision to appeal was easy, and almost a year later, we had our decision: the Judge should not have given the jury the option to consider contributory negligence. The judge has gate keeping duties requiring him to weed out meritless defenses. The defense is required to show “more than a scintilla of evidence” of contributory negligence and, in this case, the defense did not meet that standard.

This is certainly not the end to contributory negligence, but a line has been drawn. The ruling in this case is similar to a 2016 ruling in a case called Daisey v. Yost, except that this case involved a bicyclist and car driver, instead of two car drivers.

We now have another tool in our arsenal of weapons to fight for justice for cyclists in North Carolina.

Comments

Charlie Thomas Nov 08, 2024

A gap in Texas law is allowing some drivers who hit people in crosswalks to get off scot-free, despite recently passed legislation meant to address the issue. It’s called the Lisa Torry Smith Act and was passed in 2021. This law requires drivers to “stop and yield” to pedestrians, bicyclists, and anyone else legally using […]

Read More
Bike lawyer rides her bike in Charlotte, NC
Ann Groninger Jun 21, 2024

Bike Law lawyer hassled by a driver for riding in the lane. Why, because she was trying to take a left turn!

Read More
E-BIKE LAWS. ARE THEY LEGAL?
Ann Groninger Apr 04, 2024

Love them or hate them, e-bikes continue to rise in popularity. At the same time, lawmakers struggle to keep up with the developing technologies. Every week I get multiple inquiries from people trying to navigate North Carolina’s e-bike laws. If you’re confused, you’re not alone.  We could easily fill a book with all the latest […]

Read More
Ann Groninger Jan 04, 2024

Many of our cycling clients find themselves having to interact with the criminal justice system. Typically, it’s because the driver who hits them (or their family member) is charged with a crime or traffic offense. Occasionally bicyclists themselves are charged with traffic offenses! Every state’s criminal laws are different, but there is a lot of […]

Read More
Bike Crash Road Defect Georgia
Peter Wilborn Jun 14, 2023

We recently shared the story of a trial victory from the State of Texas where a bicyclist was injured due to a defect in a road maintained by the Texas Department of Transportation. Texas Road Defect   We now can tell the story of another huge win in a road defect case, this time from […]

Read More
Road defect dangerous to cyclists
Charlie Thomas Mar 14, 2023

Recently, attorneys with the Bike Law network took a case to a trial against a titan of a defendant: the Texas Department of Transportation. TxDOT was represented by the Attorney General’s Office, one of Texas’ largest legal teams. We had a great client, but it was a tough case to prove. So tough, in fact, […]

Read More
bike path charlotte
Ann Groninger Jan 13, 2023

  2023 got off to a rough start for Charlotte, North Carolina, particularly in the context of road safety. Within about a week, we lost a young woman who was riding her bicycle, a pedestrian killed in the same area of town, and four people were killed in a car wreck on I-85 in the […]

Read More
North Carolina Bike Crash
Ann Groninger Dec 06, 2022

Unless you’re a very recent follower of ours, you’ve heard us talk before about “contributory negligence.” To recap: “pure contributory negligence” is the law in North Carolina and only 3 other states (Alabama, Virginia, Maryland). In pure contributory negligence states, if a person is injured by someone else’s fault and the injured person contributes even […]

Read More
Is It Illegal to Ride Your Bike on the Sidewalk bikelaw
Peter Wilborn Aug 01, 2022

The laws dictating whether you can ride your bike on the sidewalk differ depending where you live. Different states have different laws on this matter, and local ordinances also vary. Let’s take a look at the legal framework behind various state laws related to cycling on sidewalks. The laws of sidewalk-riding can be very complicated […]

Read More
Load More