02

Blog

Motorists Must Face Criminal Charges For Killing Bicyclists

When should criminal charges be filed in collisions between cars and bicyclists? Bike Law attorney Peter Wilborn weighed in on that question in a November article in Bethesda Magazine.

The article focused on an Aug. 28 bike-car crash that took the life of Bethesda bicyclist Tim Holden. Local law enforcement officials decided not to pursue charges against the motorist who hit Holden. That sparked outrage from Bethesda riders. Greg Billing, executive director of the Washington Area Bicyclist Association, summed up the reaction of area bicyclists:

This crash specifically really struck a chord with people. Here was a person who was doing everything right while riding a bike, at least from the details that we know, and he was killed with very little consequences for the driver. When as a community and a culture are we going to stop accepting traffic deaths?

The article describes the legal options prosecutors could have pursued to charge the motorist, including: manslaughter by motor vehicle—grossly negligent driving; and criminally negligent manslaughter.

The first charge is typically used when impaired driving is present. Prosecutors said there was no evidence of that in this case. Criminally negligent manslaughter is used when a driver failed to perceive that his or her  driving created a substantial and unjustifiable risk to human life. Simple carelessness while behind the wheel is not enough for that offense, according to the article.

Based on the facts in Holden’s case, prosecutors determined that “this accident was just that; albeit a deadly one,” the article states. The motorist was eventually charged with three traffic violations and fined $690.

A fine of only $690 after killing another road user? That paltry fine appears grossly out of balance given that a fatality was involved.  It’s no wonder that area bicyclists were outraged by the outcome.

Getting Criminal Charges Filed After A Bike-Car Crash

In the Bethesda Magazine article, Peter described a 2011 Georgia bicycling fatality case he handled where prosecutors originally declined to press criminal charges. They changed their minds after reviewing a reenactment video of the fatal collision.

We looked at the video pretty carefully. The driver said he hadn’t seen the cyclists. We counted the number of seconds the cyclists were clearly visible up ahead. The prosecutor said he didn’t buy that the driver hadn’t seen him or if he didn’t see him then he must have been driving blindfolded.

The Georgia driver was charged with criminal reckless homicide.

We agree with what Greg Billing said in reaction to the resolution of the Bethesda case:

If the legal tools aren’t there, then we need the state’s attorney pushing for the tools that they need to hold drivers accountable. That’s really what it comes down to.

Greg is absolutely right. If the current law is not serving justice, let’s push for laws that do. Also, when prosecutors weigh whether to bring criminal charges against a motorist, let’s be sure they know the cycling community is watching. Let’s encourage law enforcement officials to take another look at the evidence, as Peter did in the Georgia case.  Let’s persuade our lawmakers to pass Vulnerable Road User laws. Those kinds of laws would at least provide for stiffer fines when law enforcement officials determine a fatality was an accident.

 

 

 

Comments

Denver Bicycle Riding on Sidewalk Ticket
Brian Weiss Mar 22, 2017

Bicycle commuters in Denver seem to be disproportionately targeted by the Denver Police for riding on the sidewalk when they are unable to give their side of the story.

Read More
NYC Google Maps
Daniel Flanzig Mar 20, 2017

An ongoing problem in New York State is the inability of a Police Officer to issue a traffic violation for an event they did not witness. Even if 10 witnesses confirm that a vehicle ran a red light and struck a cyclist, a Police Officer’s ability to write a summons is limited unless the event […]

Read More
Bike Law - 2017 Michigan Award
Bryan Waldman Mar 15, 2017

We weren’t able to narrow it down to 1 mechanic so we picked 3 mechanics as this year’s Bike Law Michigan Mechanic of the Year!

Read More
Spring Bike Maintenance
Arleigh Jenkins Mar 14, 2017

Read our in-house mechanic’s top tips for getting your bike ready for spring riding.

Read More
Bike Law - Victim Blaming in Bike Crashes
Arleigh Jenkins Mar 07, 2017

Bike Law network members, Lauri Boxer-Macomber (Maine) and Brian Weiss (Colorado) talk about how the media and law enforcement should treat crash reporting more fairly.

Read More
Bike Law Kickr Review
Arleigh Jenkins Feb 20, 2017

A 500-mile initial review of the Wahoo Kickr Indoor trainer, why we purchased it and who we think it is for.

Read More
Hazards of Biking with a GoPro or Garmin
Lauri Boxer-Macomber Feb 15, 2017

Did you know that there are reasons for riding with and without cameras strapped to your handlebars and embedded within your tail lights?

Read More
Cycling Law Enforcement Training in Georgia
Bruce Hagen Feb 10, 2017

CBS Atlanta News This past November, Fulton County elected a new sheriff. (Yes, there’s literally a New Sheriff in Town.) During the run-up to the election, one of the candidates posted a tasteless video of John Wayne shooting guns and seemingly taking out cyclists. This created a huge backlash. One of the candidates for Sheriff, […]

Read More
2017 Moving People Forward Conference
Arleigh Jenkins Feb 08, 2017

This past Monday I attended the Moving People Forward conference in downtown Denver. The conference was hosted by Bicycle Colorado in lieu of their annual Colorado Bike Summit which has been moved to later in the year. Leaving the conference I had mixed emotions from my attendance. As I boarded the commuter rail back to my […]

Read More
Olga Cook Ghost Bike
Daniel Flanzig Feb 02, 2017

The New Jersey man charged with felony manslaughter for striking and killing cyclist Olga Cook in the bike lane on the West Side Highway has agreed to plead guilty to all charges.

Read More
Bike Law - 2017 Fat Bike Nationals
Bryan Waldman Feb 01, 2017

A recap of the 2017 Fat Bike Nationals held in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Words from Bryan Waldman, and photo credit goes to Bike Law cyclocross racer, Wade Burch.

Read More
Cyclist Stop Sign
Brian Weiss Jan 30, 2017

Bike Law fully supports the Colorado Safety Stop Law, Senate Bill 93, that was introduced by Senator Andy Kerr to rethink the, “Operation Of Bicycles Approaching Intersections”.

Read More
Load More